---
title: "Public Shareholding Companies in Palestine (1): What Goes Unsaid Far Exceeds What Is Disclosed — Sama News Agency, 2010 | Omar Shaban Ismail"
url: "https://omarshaban.ps/publications/public-shareholding-companies-in-palestine-1?lang=en"
language: en
description: "Omar Shaban, July 2010: Palestine’s shareholding sector needs far stronger transparency and oversight than it currently faces."
---

Publication

# Public Shareholding Companies in Palestine (1): What Goes Unsaid Far Exceeds What Is Disclosed

Omar Shaban Ismail · Sama News Agency · 2010

Omar Shaban argues that public and private shareholding companies, including those linked to the Palestinian Authority, are vital to economic development and job creation, yet far less is publicly scrutinized about them than is disclosed. He traces their rapid expansion after 1994 to efforts to fill the gap created by partial disengagement from the Israeli economy and an emerging import-substitution strategy, while noting that major companies and privatized sectors such as telecommunications, energy, gas, banking, and insurance were launched before a complete legal and oversight framework existed. He criticizes monopoly arrangements, weak transparency, conflicts of interest, politicized and socially biased hiring, and the political and media influence of some firms. He also points to earlier corruption files and the Attorney General’s reference to cases worth more than $700 million, then outlines 15 issues for debate, including monopolies, contracts, taxes, wages and services, board selection and bonuses, account oversight, domestic versus external investment, annual disclosure, social responsibility, and the fate of subscribers’ funds in inactive companies.

Omar Shaban, July 2010: Palestine’s shareholding sector needs far stronger transparency and oversight than it currently faces.

(1) In the coming period, and through a series of articles, I will address the field of operation of public and private shareholding companies, as well as those owned by the Palestinian National Authority, with the aim of shedding light on these companies, their strengths and shortcomings, while emphasizing the importance of the shareholding companies sector in developing the Palestinian economy, creating job opportunities, and its major contribution to bringing the Palestinian economy and society into line with advanced economies.

Historical introduction:- It is well known that the Israeli occupation used to place obstacles and impossible requirements before the establishment of shareholding companies, whether public or private, with the aim of keeping the Palestinian economy small, family-based, and limited, making it easier to break and restrain its development. It also prevented Palestinians from thinking and working collectively and deprived the Palestinian economy of benefiting from the modest savings that might be available in the hands of ordinary citizens, as well as restraining Palestinians in the diaspora from investing part of their money inside Palestine.

With the establishment of the Palestinian National Authority in 1994, a fever for establishing shareholding companies, whether private or public, spread across all fields of investment by businessmen who possessed sufficient experience and knowledge of this type of company as a result of their work around the world, especially in the Gulf, where they quickly moved to establish private and public shareholding companies.

These companies were established with the aim of filling the vacuum that was expected as a result of the partial disengagement of the Palestinian economy from the Israeli economy, and in implementation of the import substitution policy that was beginning to crystallize among Palestinians with the aim of strengthening their economic independence. But because of the novelty of the Palestinian National Authority’s experience, and of Palestinian society in all its components—political forces, civil society, and trade union institutions—in this field, and also because all of them were preoccupied with the political concern of completing institution-building, they were not sufficiently qualified to deal with these new entities with their relatively unfamiliar legal forms. Small projects owned by one individual or a limited number of individuals were the prevailing model at that time. Large shareholding companies were established and major economic sectors were privatized, such as telecommunications, energy, and gas in the Gaza Sea, and banks, banking institutions, insurance companies, and mortgage companies were established before the completion of the legal and legislative infrastructure regulating the work of these companies and before social and cultural awareness concerning them had matured.

Is it absence or exclusion from the picture? The sector of private and public shareholding companies is still in need of further discussion in a way that strengthens transparency and official and popular oversight, especially since in past years the focus of local and international civil society institutions was directed largely at the performance of the Palestinian National Authority, which was the focus of many local and international reports that confirmed the existence of suspicions of widespread corruption, favoritism, and poor administrative performance. Meanwhile, the field of shareholding companies was not addressed to the same extent despite its importance. Therefore, the field of the private and public shareholding companies sector is dominated by much ambiguity, lack of transparency, and low levels of official and popular oversight. Despite the annual reports these companies publish on their websites, the relationship of some shareholding companies with official and societal oversight institutions is characterized by favoritism, courtesy, and conflicts of interest... which has made them, to a large extent, far removed from follow-up and scrutiny.

Some companies, especially monopolistic ones, also enjoy a great deal of influence at both the political and media levels. Many researchers and interested parties have faced the refusal of some local newspapers and news websites to publish any opinion or article that addresses these companies with criticism and questions them and their role, because these outlets depend heavily for their funding on paid advertisements from these companies.

It is also noted that some of these companies follow an unprofessional hiring policy in that they take non-objective criteria into consideration, such as family affiliation, political affiliation, and social status. Therefore, from time to time, serious and profound discussion arises in people’s minds about these companies—repeatedly in public and even more often in private—whether those owned by individuals or those affiliated with the Palestinian National Authority, such as the Palestine Investment Fund.., the Palestinian National Authority’s shares in many companies such as the telecommunications company, the power generation plant in Gaza, the gas fields discovered in the Gaza Sea, and the monopolistic contracts signed by the Palestinian National Authority in its early years, as well as the fate of some international aid funds or private funds that were looted under the name of fictitious companies that existed only on paper.

Everyone remembers that the first Palestinian Legislative Council had previously opened the files of many of these companies. Likewise, the current Attorney General, upon assuming his position years ago, stated that there were corruption files worth more than $700 million. Several years after that, we are still waiting!!! These are files proposed for the Illicit Gains Commission, which was established recently... .

Many aspects for discussion: Given the extreme importance of the sector of private shareholding companies or those owned by the Palestinian National Authority—“which is the money of the Palestinian people”—and because of the multiplicity of issues raised around them, I will address in a series of consecutive articles some important aspects related to this sector. Bearing in mind that the Palestinian people, who suffer from poverty and need in the Gaza Strip, dependence on donors in the West Bank, and poverty and dispersal in the refugee camps and at the borders, have every right not only to knowledge but also to enjoy their money and resources.

Some of these issues will be addressed in the following articles:  
1\. How the right of monopoly is granted to certain companies and not others in a given sector ... and when does the monopoly end!!  
2\. The nature of the agreements signed with these companies and the extent of their monitoring by oversight institutions.  
3\. The extent of these companies’ commitment to paying the taxes due from them.  
4\. The extent of the Authority’s and its institutions’ oversight over these companies in terms of wage levels, the level of service provided to the public, and the standards for evaluating them!!!  
5\. How members of the board of directors are selected, and the extent to which professionalism is applied and favoritism—social and political—is avoided.  
6\. Some individuals hold membership in many companies at the same time, which brings them enormous incomes and leads to flattery and hypocrisy in order to preserve a membership that generates huge income with hardly any effort.  
7\. The huge bonuses received by members of boards of directors in return for attending board meetings.  
8\. The political influence enjoyed by some shareholders and members of boards of directors.  
9\. Oversight of these companies’ accounts by the official institutions authorized to do so.  
10\. The extent of the powers granted to the Palestinian National Authority and its institutions in some of these companies’ strategic decisions, such as dismissing dozens of employees without prior notice or closing some of their branches, etc.  
11\. The percentage of funds that these companies employ in investments inside the homeland and in which fields!! And those they employ outside it.  
12\. The extent of these companies’ commitment to disclosing the results of their annual operations, as required by the Basic Law.  
13\. The extent of these companies’ cooperation with researchers wishing to study and evaluate these companies, and the making available of financial and administrative statements for public review through their websites or in discussion sessions and public dialogues, as required by law.  
14\. The extent of these companies’ contribution to social development under what is called the “Social Responsibility Fund,” as is the case in countries around the world, and how it is distributed across the different areas of the homeland!!  
15\. The fate of the funds of subscribers in companies that did not operate despite the passage of years since their establishment.

Finally, and not least, in the hope of creating a serious debate around the field of shareholding companies, whether private, public, or governmental. It is also a call to the Palestinian government headed by Dr. Salam Fayyad to look into the situation of these companies in a way that strengthens the transparency and institutionalism to which he aspires, and also a call to oversight institutions, universities, and civil society organizations to pay attention to this field of work. Emphasizing that the discussion here is not general and does not include everyone, as there are many shareholding companies that have played and continue to play an important role in national development, and they are a good example that we hope will be followed by those shareholding companies that still deal with Palestine as though it were merely an investment opportunity that must be exploited, and quickly, nothing more. To be continued...

Topic: [Gaza Economy](https://omarshaban.ps/topics/gaza-economy?lang=en) — Text © Sama News Agency — archived here with attribution to the source. — [Original source](https://samanews.ps/ar/post/73379/الشركات-المساهمة-في-فلسطين-المسكوت-عنه-أكبر-بكثير-من-المصرح-به-عمر-شعبان)

## Related publications

- [Four Years of Gaza Blockade: Some Lessons Learned](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/four-years-gaza-blockade-lessons-learned-2010?lang=en) — Common Ground News Service, 2010
- [Sustainable Development Needs a Complete Lifting of the Siege](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/sustainable-development-lifting-siege-interview-2010?lang=en) — PalThink for Strategic Studies, 2010
- [Hamas Establishes Its First Bank in Gaza](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/hamas-bank-ghaza-2010?lang=en) — Palestinian press (newspaper not recorded), 2010
- [Gaza Economy Grinds to a Standstill](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/gaza-economy-grinds-to-standstill-2009?lang=en) — PalThink for Strategic Studies, 2009
- [The Economic Repercussions of the Gaza-Egypt Border Breach](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/hudud-ghaza-misr-iqtisad-2009?lang=en) — Palestinian press (newspaper not recorded), 2009
- [Gaza Blockade!! How Much Does It Cost!](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/gaza-blockade-how-much-does-it-cost-2012?lang=en) — PalThink for Strategic Studies, 2012

[All publications](https://omarshaban.ps/publications?lang=en)

---

[Home](https://omarshaban.ps/?lang=en) · [About](https://omarshaban.ps/about?lang=en) · [Publications](https://omarshaban.ps/publications?lang=en) · [Topics](https://omarshaban.ps/topics?lang=en) · [Policy ideas](https://omarshaban.ps/policy-ideas?lang=en) · [Media archive](https://omarshaban.ps/media?lang=en) · [Facebook posts](https://omarshaban.ps/posts?lang=en) · [Timeline](https://omarshaban.ps/timeline?lang=en) · [Events](https://omarshaban.ps/events?lang=en) · [Gallery](https://omarshaban.ps/gallery?lang=en) · [Press kit](https://omarshaban.ps/press-kit?lang=en) · [Contact](https://omarshaban.ps/contact?lang=en) · [Privacy policy](https://omarshaban.ps/privacy?lang=en) · [Gaza's Economy in Figures](https://omarshaban.ps/p/gaza-economy-indicators?lang=en)

---

[العربية](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/public-shareholding-companies-in-palestine-1) · [Français](https://omarshaban.ps/publications/public-shareholding-companies-in-palestine-1?lang=fr)
